China Roundup: Tech giants take stance on Beijing’s data control in Hong Kong

China Roundup: Tech giants take stance on Beijing’s data control in Hong Kong

Hello and welcome again to TechCrunch’s China Roundup, a digest of current occasions shaping the Chinese tech panorama and what they imply to individuals in the remainder of the world.

This week, the unprecedented nationwide safety legislation descended on Hong Kong, altering the day-to-day lifetime of the individuals there, in addition to companies throughout the board. The legislation has essential implications for the tech sector, offering a litmus take a look at of enterprise sentiment in direction of China’s regulation over info. Google, Facebook, Twitter, Telegram, Zoom, Reddit amongst a roster of firms have come to voice their stance.

Resist, comply, keep away from

The Hong Kong nationwide safety legislation that went into impact on July 1 is ready to tighten Beijing’s grip over the town. Just a few provisions of the legislation instantly request service suppliers to take away info or present help to the police, as I wrote earlier. Here are what the tech giants are saying in response:

Facebook confirmed it has paused the processing of knowledge calls for from Hong Kong authorities till it may higher perceive the legislation, “together with formal human rights due diligence and consultations with human rights specialists.” Its spokesperson mentioned: “We consider freedom of expression is a basic human proper and assist the fitting of individuals to precise themselves with out worry for his or her security or different repercussions.”

Its suspension will even apply to WhatsApp, which it owns.

Twitter mentioned it suspended transfers of consumer information topic to Hong Kong calls for instantly after the legislation went into impact, and its groups are “reviewing the legislation to evaluate its implications, notably as among the phrases of the legislation are imprecise and with out clear definition.” It additionally mentioned it has “grave issues relating to each the creating course of and the total intention of this legislation.”

Read More:  Starting with Michigan, Sidewalk Infrastructure is looking to build roads specifically for autonomous cars

Google mentioned it suspended its evaluations of knowledge requests from the authorities. It added that it might proceed reviewing authorities requests for removals of user-generated content material from its companies.

Zoom mentioned it suspended its compliance with information requests from the Hong Kong authorities. “Zoom helps the free and open trade of ideas and concepts… We’re actively monitoring the developments in Hong Kong SAR, together with any potential steerage from the U.S. authorities. We have paused processing any information requests from, and associated to, Hong Kong SAR.”

LinkedIn, which is owned by Microsoft and runs a separate mainland beholden to Chinese laws, mentioned it’s pausing responses to native legislation enforcement requests because it conducts its overview of the legislation.

Telegram mentioned it doesn’t intend to course of any information requests associated to its Hong Kong customers till a global consensus is reached in relation to the continuing political adjustments within the metropolis. Its spokesperson claimed it has not disclosed any information to the Hong Kong authorities prior to now.

Signal, a competitor to Telegram within the realm of knowledge encryption, tweeted a snarky remark: “We’d announce that we’re stopping too, however we by no means began turning over consumer information to HK police. Also, we don’t have consumer information to show over.”

TikTok is in a dilemma. As a Chinese-owned firm, it may’t select to defy the Chinese authorities. On the opposite hand, it may’t afford extra narrative about it being a software of Chinese censorship. Instead of quickly refusing information requests from the police like many international companies, which is thought to be a gesture of opposition to Beijing’s grip, the quick video app determined to give up Hong Kong. It’s a straightforward enterprise choice, as the town constituted solely a tiny share of TikTok’s consumer base. Time will inform whether or not ByteDance will roll out a censored model of TikTok — Douyin — or depart the town of seven million individuals out.

Read More:  Pinterest’s $22.5M settlement highlights tech’s inequities, say former employees who alleged discrimination

Apple has lengthy been criticized for its closeness to the federal government of China, the place it has important enterprise. Last yr, it pulled a map that pinpointed pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong Kong.

Following the enactment of the safety legislation, Apple introduced it’s assessing the principles, including that it doesn’t obtain requests for consumer content material instantly from the Hong Kong authorities and requires authorities to submit requests beneath a U.S.-Hong Kong authorized help treaty.

Reddit, which counts Tencent as an investor, offered a extra evasive response: “All authorized requests from Hong Kong are sure by cautious overview for validity and with a particular consideration to human rights implications.”

The checklist just isn’t exhaustive and lots of facets of the nationwide safety legislation await additional clarification. We will maintain monitoring how different tech firms deal with the town’s new guidelines.

The tech trade involves grips with Hong Kong’s nationwide safety legislation

In response to tech companies pausing information compliance to the police, China’s Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Zhao Lijian tried to allay issues in a press release:

“I recall what Deng Xiaoping famous in 1982 when he met with Margaret Thatcher, after Hong Kong’s return to the motherland, ‘Horses will nonetheless run, shares will nonetheless sizzle, and dancers will nonetheless dance’ in Hong Kong. We have each purpose to consider that because the Law is applied, the muse of ‘one nation, two programs’ might be additional strengthened, the Hong Kong residents’ basic pursuits and wellbeing might be higher protected, there might be higher social stability and concord, and ‘horses will run sooner, shares might be extra scorching, and dancers will dance extra fortunately.’ We have full confidence in Hong Kong’s future.”

Read More:  Lawsuits allege Microsoft, Amazon and Google violated Illinois facial recognition privacy law


  • The U.S. threatens to ban TikTok over issues that it may very well be utilized by the Beijing authorities as a surveillance and propaganda software.
  • In a race to steer the worldwide semiconductor trade, Chinese chip firms have fundraised greater than twice as a lot in 2020 than in all of 2019.
  • The U.Ok. is poised to start phasing out Huawei applied sciences within the nation’s 5G community as quickly as this yr as a consequence of safety fears. The choice reversed a earlier plan to maintain Huawei within the nation’s telecom infrastructure on situation of tight restrictions.
  • Weibo is turning into a closed ecosystem. The greatest microblogging platform in China introduced it’s going to solely settle for shortened hyperlinks that it authenticates. Keeping a whitelist, it mentioned, will assist clamp down unsafe websites corresponding to unlawful playing and porn companies. Meanwhile, customers fear this can be a slippery slope that results in one other walled backyard on the web. The platform permits 4 sorts of quick hyperlinks, together with a pre-select checklist of official web sites operated by authorities branches, media, information portals, in addition to enterprise web sites vetted and authorised by Weibo.


Add comment